Matthew 17:24-27 – The Temple Tax

BIBLE TEXT

Matthew 17:24-27

Summary

Jesus offers two shocking pieces of advice to Peter regarding the Temple tax. 

Analysis

When the collectors ask whether Jesus pays the Temple tax, it is unclear whether Peter says “yes” out of truth or embarrassment. We can guess, however, that it was out of embarrassment, since Matthew goes on to point out that Jesus “spoke of it first” and calls Peter by his Hebrew name “Simon” instead of his nickname. The question that Jesus addresses to Peter also hints at his unhappiness with Peter’s response. To understand his point, it is important to know that taxation in the ancient world was often associated with colonial administration. Rather than tax its own citizens, an empire like Rome would conquer a neighboring kingdom and force them to pay taxes. In other words, Jesus calls the Temple tax nonsensical, as it forces those who belong to the Temple “kingdom” to pay its taxes. Jesus offers further surprises. Despite his criticism and despite his adversarial relationship to the Temple authorities, Jesus commands Peter to save face and pay the tax.