1 Chronicles 17:1-27 – God’s Promise to David

BIBLE TEXT

1 Chronicles 17:1-27

SUMMARY

In this pivotal chapter, God promises that David will always have a son on the throne of Judah (vv. 1-15), and David responds with thanks and praise (vv. 16-27).

ANALYSIS

God’s covenant with David (1 Chronicles 17:3-15) and God’s promise of forgiveness to Solomon at the dedication of the Temple (2 Chronicles 7:11-22) form the two pillars upon which the Chronicler’s theology is structured: king and cult. As usual, the Chronicler has reframed the earlier material from Samuel to allow the text to speak to the concerns of his own postexilic community.

Here, the Chronicler has followed his source (2 Samuel 7) very closely. There, as here, God’s promise is developed through a delightful play on the ambiguous nature of the 14 occurrences of the Hebrew word for “house,” variously signifying the “palace” where David lives (v. 1), “the Temple” he wishes to build for God (v. 4), or the “dynasty” of his descendants who will sit upon his throne (vv. 10b, 14). There, as here, though, God will not permit David to build a house (Temple) for the Lord (v. 4). Instead, God will build a house (dynasty) for David (v. 10b), and one member of that dynastic house (i.e., Solomon) will build the house (Temple) for God (v. 12a).

The small differences between 2 Samuel 7 and 1 Chronicles 17, however, are significant:

  • The Chronicler omits the mention of the exodus in 2 Samuel 7:6. Some commentators have suggested that this omission occurs because the Chronicler understood the deliverance from Egypt to have been eclipsed for his community by the activity of David and their own return from Babylon. However, the Chronicler’s retention of the information from 2 Samuel 7:23—in which David describes the people of Israel as those whom God “redeemed for yourself from Egypt” (1 Chronicles 17:21)—somewhat undercuts the view that the exodus had been superseded by the restoration from exile.
  • The reference to Solomon’s expected sin and God’s punishment (2 Samuel 7:14) is left out for the same reason that David’s peccadilloes are omitted.
  • Most important, God says that Solomon, not David, will be confirmed as king in the kingdom that is described as belonging to God, not to David (1 Chronicles 17:14, contrast 2 Samuel 7:16).