Matthew 16:1-4 – The Hopelessness of Signs Again

BIBLE TEXT

Matthew 16:1-4

Summary

For the second time, Jesus testifies that his ministry does not need signs from heaven to confirm its power.

Analysis

This is the second instance in which the opponents of Jesus ask him for a sign from heaven to confirm his ministry. The first time, Jesus invoked the Old Testament and the prophet Moses to argue that signs do not lead to faith. In response to this challenge, Jesus turns instead to popular folk wisdom, citing a set of proverbs similar to the modern English saying “Red sky at night, sailor’s delight; red sky at morn, sailor be warned.” 

Once again, Jesus’ response hinges on a different understanding of “signs.” The Pharisees and the Sadducees are looking for a “sign from heaven,” that is a miraculous confirmation of Jesus’ authority. Jesus instead points them to mundane interpretation of the weather to make the point that they can’t see the obvious holy nature of his ministry. He leaves them once again with the reference to the “sign of Jonah,” with its undertones of non-Israelites receiving the preaching of the Gospel.